Alan Austin updates IA's running tally of hypocrisies and broken promises by Australia's most mendacious ever prime minister — Tony Abbott.
The one positive to emerge from the most destructive budget in
Australia’s post-war history is that it has silenced all those claiming
Tony Abbott and Joe Hockey are honourable men.
No-one can now claim they are governing in the nation’s interest.
No-one can assert they tell the truth. No-one can deny that they have
broken multiple promises.
As recently as 3 May, Rupert Murdoch’s mendacious national paper The Australian ran a story headed
‘Abbott didn’t break any promises’.
Here at Independent Australia, however, 25 specific broken commitments were documented in early February.
The Murdoch media have now changed tack: Okay, Abbott and Hockey have broken a few dozen promises. But who cares?
They are pushing this line quite openly now, with headlines such as ‘Our futile fascination with broken promises’ in the Daily Telegraph.
On the positive side, Fairfax publications have broken ranks with Murdoch and are calling the shattered assurances for what they are.
So, what is the official IA tally of broken promises and blatant hypocrisies?
The first 13 were documented in November.
The next 12 were detailed here in February.
They related to:
1. There have been no broken promises
2. Respecting a government’s mandate
3. Freedom of information
4. Toowoomba Range bypass plan
5. Reporting the budget position
6. Justifying the debt ceiling
7. Reducing the nation’s debt
8. Returning the budget to surplus
9. The UN Security Council seat
10. Foreign minister’s first trip abroad
11. Relations with the region
12. National broadband network
13. Stopping the boats
14. Spending his first week with the Yolngu
15. Open and accountable government
16. Cuts to pensions
17. School attendances
18. Government job for Sophie Mirabella
19. No deals with the Greens
20. ABC and SBS funding
21. Subsidies to industries
22. Monitoring whaling
23. Increased funds for aid agencies
24. Entering Indonesia waters
25. We will not tow back the boats
That list has been expanded with several bizarre decisions, some Abbott took with no consultation with cabinet colleagues.
26. No knighthoods for Australia
In December 2013 Abbott ruled out reinstating the archaic regal gongs, saying:
“I just don't think that's realistic in this country.”
Thirteen weeks later, Abbot reinstated knighthoods.
27. No public servants to be forced out of work
Abbott was explicit before the election: “no forced redundancies”.
In Parliament, however, it was disclosed that Department of Industry employees have been forced out.
28. Incarcerating children offshore
In 2012, Opposition shadow treasurer Joe Hockey – now treasurer – actually wept in Parliament over this outrageous idea:
“I will never ever support a people swap where you can send a
13-year-old child unaccompanied to a country without supervision —
never! It will be over my dead body. How dare people!”
Now in power, the Abbott Government is sending children, including those with no family, into imprisonment at Nauru and Manus Island.
Immigration Minister Scott Morrison told a November 2013 press conference:
“… it doesn’t matter whether you’re a child, it doesn’t matter
whether you’re pregnant, it doesn’t matter whether you’re a woman, it
doesn’t matter whether you’re an unaccompanied minor, it doesn’t matter
if you have a health condition, if you’re fit enough to get on a boat
then you can expect you’re fit enough to end up in offshore processing.”
The list of smashed promises expanded substantially when last week’s budget broke Abbott’s few remaining pre-election pledges:
"No cuts to education, no cuts to health, no change to pensions, no change to the GST and no cuts to the ABC or SBS."
29. No cuts to education
The promise was explicit: that Labor’s funding under the Gonski reforms would be matched and “no school would be worse off” over the next four years.
In the Budget, however, school funding rises by just $54.1m in 2017-18, which effectively freezes school funding at the 2017 level in real terms.
30. Raising university fees
Education Minister Christopher Pyne was adamant on Sky News in November 2013:
“We’re not going to raise fees. I’m not even considering it because we promised that we wouldn’t.”
The budget slashed
funding for university courses and exposed students to huge debt
increases with the removal of caps on fees universities can charge.
31. No cuts to health
In August, Abbott said:
“I am giving an absolute commitment that the overall levels of health funding will be maintained."
The budget announced,
however, that hospital funding agreements with the states and
territories under Labor will be wound back from 2017, cutting a massive
$50 billion over eight years.
32. Closing Medicare locals
Before the election, Abbott was explicit in response to a direct question:
"We are not shutting any Medicare Locals."
The budget announced that the entire network of 61 community health centres will be scrapped.
33. Funding on direct action
According to Climate Spectator, the budget shows annual funding allocations from 2014-15 to 2017-18 for the government’s centrepiece climate change program
'... are $1.4 billion lower, or less than half, what the Coalition had promised before the 2013 Federal Election.'
34. Consultancy spending to be cut
Abbott in opposition repeatedly promised to cut spending by
“... vastly reducing the number of consultancies ...”
The May budget allocates a staggering $91 million to pay consultants from the top end of town for their advice on the sale of Medibank Private.
35. Aboriginal land rights
At the Garma festival in north-east Arnhem Land last August Abbott promised to
“... do whatever I humanly can in government to bring this [improved land rights for Aboriginal people] about."
As funding for research and for legal aid for land claims across
Australia is critical, all Aboriginal land claimants were looking
expectantly at the May budget.
They got nothing.
36. No new taxes
The deficit levy imposes an extra 2% tax on all income above $180,000 a year.
37. Using the state of the economy as an excuse for breaking promises
Melbourne ABC Radio host Jon Faine
challenged Abbott directly on the likelihood he would blame the state
of the economy for changing his policies after the election.
Abbott denied this possibility point blank:
"It is an absolute principle of democracy that governments should
not and must not say one thing before an election and do the opposite
Yet after the election Abbott has done precisely that. Forty times.
38. This will be a government of no surprises
The New Daily:
The one secret they didn’t tell us before the budget is that the
Federal government plans to save $80 billion over the next ten years by
giving the states less money to run our schools and hospitals.
The other big surprise in this budget is that, over the government’s first four years, it makes hardly any net savings at all.
39. The burden will be shared evenly
Abbott and Hockey repeatedly said that the heavy lifting would be shared across the community.
All reliable analysis shows that, in contrast, the poor are hit hardest – losing as much as 10% of their income – while the rich are barely slugged at all.
40. Families should be off limits in politics
Abbott and his wife shamelessly exploited their three daughters
through the 2013 election campaign to construct the perception that
theirs was a functional nuclear family.
Now, with daughter Frances in the spotlight over what appears on the surface to be corrupt payments for her degree, Abbott declares:
“I think family should be off-limits when it comes to party political contention."
That’s 40 broken promises and blatant hypocrisies. In just 37 weeks.
Questions arising include these:
Has there ever been a government in any modern democracy with a record of duplicity this extensive so soon in a term of office?
What do Abbott’s colleagues make of this tawdry performance? How long
before Abbott is challenged by Malcolm Turnbull or another ambitious
Meanwhile, what does it do to the nation’s moral standing and sense
of pride and confidence to have a proven liar and conman as elected
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia License